Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. These links, if used and purchases made, we may earn a small commission. These affiliate programs do not impact the recommendations we make or the resources we refer you to. Our focus is on providing you the best resources for your nonprofit journey.

When Does Hiring a Nonprofit Consultant Actually Make Sense?

Not every problem needs a consultant. But some problems will eat your organization alive if you try to solve them internally without the right expertise. Knowing the difference is the first step in preparing to hire well.

A consultant makes sense when your team lacks specific technical knowledge – think Salesforce implementation, major gift fundraising strategy, or merging two organizations. It also makes sense when you need an outside perspective that internal politics make impossible. Board dysfunction, executive transitions, and strategic planning often benefit from someone who does not have a stake in the outcome.

Where nonprofits get into trouble is hiring a consultant as a substitute for leadership. If your executive director cannot articulate what the organization needs, a consultant will not magically figure it out for you. They will bill hours trying, and you will end up frustrated.

Before you start searching, ask yourself three honest questions:

Can we clearly describe the problem we need solved?
Do we have the internal capacity to implement whatever the consultant recommends?
Is our leadership aligned on the need for outside help?

If you answered no to any of those, you have pre-work to do before spending money on a consultant.

Get Your House in Order First

The single biggest predictor of a successful consulting engagement is how prepared the nonprofit is before the work begins. Consultants are not miracle workers. They are skilled professionals who need raw materials to work with.

Here is what you should gather and organize before you even write a job description:

Organizational Documents

Pull together your strategic plan (if you have one), recent board meeting minutes, financial statements from the last two to three years, and any previous consultant reports. If you are hiring for a fundraising consultant, have your donor database export ready along with giving history and campaign results. For an operations consultant, compile your org chart, employee handbook, and any process documentation you have.

Do not worry if these documents are imperfect. A good consultant expects some messiness. But having nothing to hand over signals that the organization is not ready for the engagement.

Internal Alignment

This is where most engagements go sideways before they even start. The board chair wants one thing, the ED wants another, and the development director has a completely different vision for what the consultant should do.

Before you hire anyone, get your key stakeholders in a room and answer these questions together:

What specific outcome do we want from this engagement?
Who will be the primary point of contact for the consultant?
What does success look like in six months? In a year?
What are we willing to change as a result of this work?

That last question matters more than you think. If the answer is “nothing, we just want validation,” save your money.

Staff Buy-In

Your staff will make or break a consulting engagement. If they see the consultant as a threat or an imposition from leadership, they will withhold information, skip meetings, and quietly undermine the work. Brief your team early. Explain why you are bringing in outside help, what it means for their roles, and how their input will be valued in the process.

Defining the Scope of Work

Vague scopes produce vague results. “Help us with fundraising” is not a scope of work. “Assess our current major gifts program, identify gaps, and deliver a 12-month action plan with staffing recommendations” is a scope of work.

A well-defined scope should include:

The specific deliverables – What tangible products will the consultant produce? Reports, plans, training sessions, facilitated meetings?
The timeline – When does the work start and end? Are there milestones along the way?
The boundaries – What is explicitly outside the scope? This prevents mission creep on both sides.
The decision-makers – Who approves deliverables? Who can request changes?
The access required – What data, staff time, and systems will the consultant need?

Write this down before you talk to a single consultant. You can refine it during conversations, but starting with a clear framework saves everyone time and protects you from consultants who want to expand the engagement beyond what you need.

Setting a Realistic Budget

Nonprofit leaders often have no idea what consultants cost, and that disconnect creates problems. You will find consultants charging anywhere from $75 to $350 per hour, with most experienced nonprofit consultants landing between $125 and $250 per hour. Project-based fees are common and often preferable because they shift the risk of scope creep to the consultant.

When budgeting, account for more than just the consultant’s fee:

Staff time – Your people will spend hours in meetings, gathering data, and reviewing drafts. That has a real cost.
Travel – If the consultant is not local, who covers travel expenses?
Implementation – The consultant’s recommendations will cost money to execute. Budget for that now, not later.
Contingency – Add 10 to 15 percent for the unexpected. Scopes change, timelines shift, and additional needs emerge.

If your budget is tight, be upfront about it. A good consultant will tell you what is achievable within your means rather than overpromising. A bad one will say yes to everything and deliver on nothing.

One more thing on budget: do not automatically choose the cheapest option. In consulting, you genuinely get what you pay for. A $5,000 strategic plan from someone with no nonprofit experience will cost you far more in wasted time and bad advice than a $15,000 engagement with a proven expert.

Writing a Request for Proposals

You do not always need a formal RFP. For smaller engagements under $10,000, a clear email describing the work and asking for a proposal is often sufficient. But for larger projects, an RFP brings structure and makes it easier to compare candidates.

A solid nonprofit RFP includes:

Organization background – A brief description of your mission, size, budget, and current situation. Two to three paragraphs is enough.
Project description – What you need done, why, and what prompted the need.
Scope of work – Your draft scope, with a note that you are open to the consultant’s input on refining it.
Timeline – When you need the work completed and any hard deadlines.
Budget range – Yes, include this. Consultants waste less of everyone’s time when they know the ballpark. If your budget is $10,000 and the consultant’s minimum is $25,000, better to find that out before either of you invests hours in conversations.
Submission requirements – What you want in the proposal (approach, timeline, budget breakdown, references, relevant experience).
Selection criteria – How you will evaluate proposals. This forces you to think about what actually matters to you.
Deadline and contact info – When proposals are due and who to direct questions to.

Send the RFP to at least three consultants. Ask colleagues at peer organizations for referrals. Check professional associations like the Nonprofit Consulting Group or your local nonprofit association’s consultant directory.

Evaluating Consultants the Right Way

Credentials and certifications matter less than you think in nonprofit consulting. What matters is relevant experience, a clear methodology, and strong references from organizations similar to yours.

During your evaluation, pay attention to:

How they listen – Does the consultant ask thoughtful questions about your situation, or do they jump straight into pitching their solution? The best consultants spend more time listening than talking in initial conversations.
Their honesty – A consultant who tells you what you do not want to hear during the proposal phase is worth their weight in gold. One who agrees with everything you say is either inexperienced or desperate for the contract.
Relevant examples – Ask for specific examples of similar work. Not just client names, but what they did, what challenges they encountered, and what the outcomes were.
Cultural fit – Your staff will work closely with this person. Do they communicate in a style that works for your team? Are they comfortable with your organization’s pace and culture?
References – Call them. Actually call them. Ask what went well, what did not, and whether they would hire the consultant again. The pause before that last answer tells you everything.

Setting Expectations for the Engagement

Once you have selected a consultant, invest time upfront in setting clear expectations. This is not just about the deliverables – it is about how you will work together.

Cover these items before work begins:

Communication cadence – How often will you check in? Weekly calls? Biweekly emails? Define this upfront.
Response times – How quickly should each side respond to emails and requests? Consultants juggle multiple clients. Knowing their availability prevents frustration.
Feedback process – How will you provide feedback on drafts and deliverables? Who needs to review what? Build in realistic review periods.
Change management – What happens if the scope needs to change? Define a process for scope modifications, including how additional costs are handled.
Confidentiality – What information is sensitive? Can the consultant reference your organization in their marketing materials?

Put all of this in a written agreement. A formal contract protects both parties and prevents the “I thought we agreed to…” conversations that derail engagements.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

After years of watching nonprofit consulting engagements succeed and fail, certain patterns repeat themselves:

Hiring too early. If you cannot clearly articulate what you need, you are not ready. Do the internal work first.

Hiring too late. Waiting until you are in crisis means the consultant is doing triage instead of strategic work. You will pay more and get less.

Skipping the reference check. Every consultant looks great on paper and in person. References reveal the full picture.

Not assigning an internal lead. Someone on your team needs to own this relationship. Without a dedicated point person, communication fragments, deadlines slip, and the engagement drifts.

Expecting the consultant to do your job. A consultant advises and builds capacity. They do not replace your leadership team. If you are hoping they will make hard decisions for you, reset your expectations.

Ignoring the recommendations. This happens more often than anyone admits. The consultant delivers a solid plan, it sits on a shelf, and six months later the organization is back to square one. Before you hire, commit to acting on what you learn.

The Bottom Line

Hiring a nonprofit consultant is an investment. Like any investment, the return depends largely on the preparation you put in beforehand. Organizations that do the hard work of aligning their leadership, defining their needs, setting realistic budgets, and choosing the right partner consistently get better results.

Take the time to prepare. Your future self – and your organization – will thank you for it.

More Nonprofit Consultant Resources