Maximizing Board Effectiveness: Choosing the Best Nonprofit Board Management Software

Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. These links, if used and purchases made, we may earn a small commission. These affiliate programs do not impact the recommendations we make or the resources we refer you to. Our focus is on providing you the best resources for your nonprofit journey.

Your board members are busy professionals who donate their time. If your current board management process involves emailing 47-page PDF packets, chasing RSVPs in text threads, and hoping everyone reads the financials before the meeting – you’re making their job harder than it needs to be. Board management software solves this by centralizing documents, streamlining meeting prep, and giving board members a single place to do their governance work. This guide helps you choose the right tool, get board buy-in, and implement it in 30 days.

Do You Actually Need Board Management Software?

Answer these questions:

• Do you spend more than 2 hours preparing and distributing each board packet?
• Do board members frequently show up to meetings without having read the materials?
• Do you struggle to track who’s responded to meeting invites, votes, or document reviews?
• Is your board document archive scattered across email, Google Drive, and someone’s desktop?
• Do you have trouble maintaining confidentiality of sensitive board materials?

If you answered “yes” to 3 or more: you need dedicated board software. If 1-2: a well-organized Google Drive or SharePoint folder might suffice for now. If zero: nice work, keep going.

The Top Board Management Platforms Compared

Here’s a practical comparison of the most widely used platforms, based on what nonprofit leaders actually care about:

Boardable – Best for Small-to-Mid Nonprofits

• Price: Free tier (basic features, 1 board), Essential $79/month, Professional $199/month
• Best for: Organizations with budgets under $5M that want simplicity
• Key features: Meeting scheduling with agenda builder, document library, task assignments, minutes, e-signatures, voting
• Pros: Clean interface, easy for non-tech-savvy board members, affordable, good mobile app
• Cons: Limited customization, reporting is basic on lower tiers
• Setup time: 1-2 weeks

BoardEffect – Best for Larger/Complex Organizations

• Price: Custom pricing (typically $5,000-15,000/year depending on board size and features)
• Best for: Organizations with budgets over $5M, multiple committees, or complex governance needs
• Key features: Board book builder, committee management, policy library, D&O questionnaires, assessments, audit trail
• Pros: Purpose-built for governance, excellent compliance features, strong security
• Cons: Steeper learning curve, higher cost, may be overkill for simple boards
• Setup time: 3-6 weeks with vendor support

OnBoard (by Passageways) – Best Balance of Features and Usability

• Price: Custom pricing (typically $4,000-12,000/year)
• Best for: Mid-size organizations wanting robust features without enterprise complexity
• Key features: Intelligent board book builder, real-time collaboration, voting, minutes, meeting analytics (shows who opened documents)
• Pros: Intuitive interface, excellent meeting analytics, good customer support
• Cons: Mid-range pricing may stretch smaller budgets
• Setup time: 2-4 weeks

DIY Option – Google Workspace or Microsoft 365

• Price: Free for nonprofits
• Best for: Small organizations with simple governance needs and tight budgets
• How to set it up: Create a shared Drive/SharePoint folder structure: Board Meeting [Date] – Agenda, Financials, Committee Reports, Minutes. Use Google Calendar or Outlook for scheduling. Use Google Forms for voting.
• Pros: Free, familiar tools, no new software to learn
• Cons: No governance-specific features, no audit trail, security depends on your configuration, more manual work for staff

Decision Framework: Which Platform Is Right for You?

• Budget under $500K or board of 5-8: Boardable free tier or DIY with Google/Microsoft
• Budget $500K-$2M or board of 8-15: Boardable Essential/Professional
• Budget $2M-$10M with committees: OnBoard or Boardable Professional
• Budget over $10M with complex governance: BoardEffect or OnBoard

How to Get Board Buy-In (The Hard Part)

The technology isn’t the challenge – getting board members to actually use it is. Here’s the playbook:

1. Start with the board chair. Get them on board first. If the chair uses and promotes the platform, others follow. Demo it in a 15-minute one-on-one.
2. Frame it as respecting their time. “This will cut your meeting prep from 45 minutes to 10 minutes. Everything in one place, accessible from your phone.” Board members are busy – appeal to efficiency.
3. Don’t ask for a vote – ask for a pilot. “Let’s try this for two meetings. If the board doesn’t find it useful, we’ll go back to email.” Low-risk trials reduce resistance.
4. Offer setup assistance. Have a staff member individually help any board member who struggles with technology. A 10-minute phone call to walk someone through login and navigation eliminates 90% of adoption friction.
5. Stop sending materials via email. After the transition, all board materials go through the platform only. If you keep emailing packets as a “backup,” people will never switch.

Implementation Checklist: Go Live in 30 Days

Week 1: Setup

• – Select your platform (use the decision framework above)
• – Sign up and configure your organization’s account
• – Upload board member profiles and contact information
• – Create your committee structure
• – Upload key governance documents: bylaws, conflict of interest policy, strategic plan, last 3 months of meeting minutes

Week 2: Populate and Prepare

• – Build your first meeting agenda in the platform
• – Upload the full board packet for your next meeting
• – Create a 1-page “Getting Started” guide for board members (login URL, how to view documents, how to RSVP)
• – Demo the platform for the board chair and get their endorsement

Week 3: Invite Board Members

• – Send invitations with the 1-page guide
• – Offer individual setup calls for anyone who needs help
• – Follow up with anyone who hasn’t logged in within 3 days
• – Post the meeting agenda and materials exclusively through the platform

Week 4: First Meeting

• – Run your board meeting using the platform for agenda, documents, and attendance
• – Take minutes directly in the platform
• – After the meeting: upload approved minutes, collect feedback from board members
• – Address any issues before the next meeting

Your Next Steps

• This week: Take the needs assessment at the top of this article. If you score 3+, start evaluating platforms.
• Next week: Demo 2-3 platforms (most offer free trials). Include your board chair in at least one demo.
• This month: Make your selection and begin the 30-day implementation checklist above.
• Next board meeting: Run your first meeting on the new platform.

Good governance starts with good infrastructure. The right board management tool won’t fix a disengaged board, but it removes the friction that keeps engaged board members from doing their best work. Pick a platform, get the chair on board, and implement it before your next meeting cycle.